Anaerobic Digestion

Solution Strengths, Weaknesses and Critical Indicators

Anaerobic Digestion:

  • Long usable life and can be run reliably
  • Creates energy and generates environmental credits
  • Proper feeding & system monitoring is required to avoid system downtime
  • Proven technology for odor control
  • Proven technology for GHG reduction
  • Proven technology for pathogen reduction
  • Different types of systems produce varying gas production rates
  • Requires proper preparation of the feedstock
  • Requires other technologies for energy utilization
  • Requires other technologies for digestate handling
  • Requires other technologies to prevent nitrogen loss
  • Complex systems may require expertise not available on-farm

Overall Summary

 Primary Application

  • Dairy farms with over 500 cows or farms with meaningful organics for co-digestion.
  • Vacuumed/scraped manure, manure slurries, bedded pack that is diluted with digester effluent.

 Economic/Return on Investment Considerations

  • Economics are almost always a challenge; on a value of renewable energy basis, AD is hard to justify, at present received prices for electricity and gas.
  • AD does provide several non-monetary benefits to a farm (see below).

 Industry Uptake

  • 200 dairy-based U.S. installations and thousands worldwide.

Technology Maturity

  • Refined, standard designs available from multiple technology providers.

Primary Benefits

  • Odor reduction – 70 to 95% reduction of indicator acids.
  • Manure organic matter reduction – 35%.
  • Renewable electrical energy production – 2,000 kWh/cow possible each year.
  • Pathogen reduction – 90%+ elimination of fecal coliform organisms as a typical indicator pathogen.
  • Greenhouse gas emission reduction – amount varies by location and farm-specific, but reductions can be large, on the order of 67%+.
  • Nutrient preservation/transformation – key crop nutrients in manure are not consumed by AD and the nutrient form is more plant available than when not digested.
  • Contributes to society’s goal for organic landfill diversion – co-digestion easily achieved enhancing above benefits.

Secondary Benefits

  • Pre-treatment for tertiary treatments like ammonia stripping.
  • Post treatment of waste separation can produce adequate recycled manure solids for bedding livestock.
  • Renewable thermal heat production – 13,500 Btu’s/cow or more possible each year.
  • Nutrients converted for a more plant available form.
  • Increased crop yields possible.
  • Possible reduction of impact on water quality.

How it Works

  • Raw or pre-treated manure is conveyed into a gas tight vessel on a regular basis (daily or more often) that operates at a set temperature (38 ⁰C in most cases).
  • Naturally occurring microbes in manure break solids down into energy-rich biogas.
  • Biogas is used to fuel engine-generators to make electricity or is cleaned to make a natural gas replacement.
  • Some of the produced gas, or heat produced by an engine-generator set is used to heat the digester making it a net energy production system.

 Pre-treatment and/or Post-treatment Required

  • Pre-treatment not required when organic material is used to bed stalls and/or when manure is not substantially diluted. Pre-treatment to remove bedding sand is required with sand-bedded stalls.
  • Pre-treatment may be used to remove excess moisture from influent from barns where hydraulic flushing is used.
  • Post-treatment not required but may be employed based on overall goals of the manure treatment system.

Limitations

  • Does not reduce volume.
  • Does not work well with raw manure containing bedding sand.
  • Does not work with highly diluted manure due to cost and heat demands for a large vessel.

Other Considerations

  • Currently, most systems are farmer managed, more consistent results may be achieved by dedicated operators.
  • Adding co-digestible material will increase the nutrient content of the digestate and will need to be addressed in the nutrient management plan.
  • A portion of nutrients are converted from organic to inorganic. More nutrients are available for immediate update by crops, so nutrient management plans should be updated to reduce the potential for water quality concerns.

Solutions Providers in order of 9-Point Scoring System

Fermentation represents a natural and anaerobic dissimilation process during which organic biomass is transformed into simpler organic compouds. Certain bacterial strains are capable of converting organic material mainly into methane (CH4), carbon dioxide (CO2) and water. The efficiency of the conversion is determined by the system and the nature of…
[tech_score]
CH4 Energy is forever developing ways to better manage organics in our business and for CH4 Energy’s partners. This includes connecting greenhouses to anaerobic digesters and developing fertilizer systems to further the recycling efforts. By operating CH4 Energy’s business this way, CH4 Energy has become vertically oriented in managing organics.
[tech_score]
CH4 Biogas plants produce renewable energy by anaerobically digesting livestock manure and food-grade organic wastes. CH4 Biogas’ partner, Bigadan A/S, pioneered the co-digestion concept that has been the operating model for the Danish biogas industry for over 25 years.
[tech_score]
CH Four Biogas is a North American leader in anerobic digestion technologies. CH Four has a North American supply chain and offer a full suite of services from design and permitting, through installation and operations. With over a decade of experience and operating systems, CH Four has established a reputation…
[tech_score]
Cenergy USA, Inc. works with project developers on the installation of DVO’s patented Two Stage Linear VortexTM digester systems.  DVO digester systems greatly reduce odors, are cost-effective, scalable, operate automatically and require low maintenance. Additionally, DVO digester produces pathogen free bedding and offer technologies to recover phosphorus and nitrogen from…
[tech_score]
Camco works at the early stage of the biogas project development process. Camco has expertise, resources, and capital to work to advance projects from concept to implementation. This could entail advancing a project though the early permitting, feed stock negotiations, off-take contracting (PPA or commodity sales), engineering, technology selection and…
[tech_score]
California Bioenergy develops, owns, and operates projects in partnership with the dairy farmer. The projects capture and destroy methane produced from dairy cow waste, creating renewable electricity, bio-methane or transportation fuel and in the process greenhouse gas emissions reductions. CalBio’s process consists of four main steps: Waste Collection Gas Capture…
[tech_score]
Waste-to-Energy Waste-to-energy is the process of creating energy in the form of electricity or heat from a waste source. WtE is a form of energy recovery. Most WtE processes produce energy through combustion, which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions, whereby, the BioStar anaerobic digestion waste to energy process does not.…
[tech_score]
Biogas Corporation is a project developer that specializes in projects which are tailor made to the specific region, project, and/or farm. Biogas Corporation will use a host of available technologies in a systems approach to produce multiple co-products to maximize financial feasibility and response to project needs. These co-products include…
[tech_score]
Complete mix mesophilic digesters are the most widely deployed AD technology in the world. While there are perhaps a dozen projects operating in the US (the Biogas Energy team built six of them), over five thousand are going strong in Europe. As a licensed contractor in California, Biogas Energy will…
[tech_score]